Sunday, November 15, 2026

NAME THE SCHOOL, SHOW THE PROOF: SAMIK BHATTACHARYA OWES BENGAL'S CHRISTIANS A PUBLIC APOLOGY

 


A sweeping charge of forced conversion and "anti-India activities", unsupported by a single name, date or document, sits on top of a documented record of mobs raiding prayer meetings. It is the accuser, not the accused, who has questions to answer.

A Charge Without an Address

On Sunday, standing on a dais in New Alipore, the Bengal BJP president, Samik Bhattacharya, did what no responsible leader should do: he indicted an entire community without naming a single accused. Christian missionary schools, he suggested, force conversions. They sneer at the attire of the majority. They harbour "anti-India activities". Unless they mend their ways, he warned, the schools will not be allowed to run.

Not one school was named. Not one date was offered. No complainant, no FIR, no document was produced. What the audience received instead were anecdotes with the proper nouns carefully removed: an "elite college", a "prestigious school", "a school in Calcutta". And a threat.

An allegation that cannot be checked is not an allegation. It is a smear. And a smear delivered by the head of the ruling party, in a state where Christian bodies say congregations are already being raided on the strength of identical rumours, is not merely irresponsible. It is dangerous.

"Asansol" and the Principal Who Has No Name

"In Asansol, religious conversion is currently taking place," Mr Bhattacharya declared, in the present continuous tense, as though he were watching it unfold. In the same speech he said the conversion was being run by the principal of an obhijato college in Calcutta.

Which college? Which principal? Which converts, converted through what force, what fraud, what bribe? Silence.

The Bangiya Christiya Pariseba has answered the charge in plain words: no such conversion is taking place, and it wants the government to investigate. Pause on that. The community accused of a crime is begging the state to open an inquiry. The accuser, whose party runs that state and its police, will not hand over a name. Who, exactly, has something to hide?

The Pariseba did not stop at denial. It said it opposes unlawful conversion, backs legal action against any violator, and wants the allegations probed. Church bodies have reportedly gone further, tightening their own safeguards so that those seeking to embrace Christianity must submit a written application and an affidavit. That is not how a conversion racket behaves. It is how a community behaves when it is trying to protect itself from a false charge.

The Pakistani Flag Nobody Can Find

"Guardians, arise!" Mr Bhattacharya cried, claiming that an official at a school had placed a Pakistani flag on a table in a chamber somewhere in Calcutta.

If that is true, it is a matter for the police and the education department, not a podium. The Christian forum said as much: if such an act took place, it condemns it, and it asked him to name the school. He has not. A leader who truly believed a school was harbouring a hostile symbol would have filed a complaint the same day. Besides, keeping various national flags is not a crime, – instead, it stands of solidarity and unity. A leader who wants a rumour to do its work keeps the name secret, because a rumour that cannot be tested also cannot be disproved.

The consequence is plain. By refusing to name the institution, Mr Bhattacharya has placed every Christian school in West Bengal under a cloud. Each principal, each teacher, each child in a missionary uniform now carries a suspicion that he alone created and that he alone can lift.

A Saffron Sari, a School Gate and a Threat

The third anecdote concerned a young woman worker of his party, allegedly told by a "Bengali teacher" at a "prestigious school" that she could not wear saffron saris to the school and must never utter the name of Lord Krishna before the students.

Note what this is: a second-hand story, about an unnamed teacher, at an unnamed school, with no complaint on record. If any teacher truly said such things, the remedy lies with the school's governing body, the education department or the courts, and every decent Christian institution would act on a proper complaint. Instead Mr Bhattacharya announced, "in a few days, I'll stand at the school gate."

Picture it. A party president, flanked by party workers, planted at the gate of a school, in front of children, to confront a teacher. That is not a grievance. That is pressure, and the intended audience is every teacher in Bengal who is now being told to watch what she says.

The contradiction is breathtaking. In the same speech he said his party is "against political intervention in any educational institution". Standing at the school gate is political intervention in its purest form. As a recent Telegraph opinion piece by Valson Thampu and Debasish Bhattacharyya reminded readers, when education becomes an instrument of political mobilisation, overt or covert, its core purpose is eroded. Schools are for learning. They are not stage sets for a party's campaign.

Babur, the British and the Politics of Insult

"This government is not Babur's government," Mr Bhattacharya thundered. "This government is not trying to uphold British legacies." Seventy-five years on, he lamented, the colonial "mentality has not gone".

Who is being addressed here? The Bengali Catholic or Protestant who was born in Howrah or Barasat, who speaks Bengali at home, who pays taxes and votes in Indian elections? To compare such a citizen to a Mughal invader or a colonial administrator is the oldest trick in the book: turn a neighbour into a foreigner, and every injustice done to him becomes easier to excuse.

Christians in West Bengal are no more "British" than Hindus are "Mughal". They are Bengalis. They are Indians. Their faith is their business, protected by Article 25 of the Constitution, and their right to establish and run their own educational institutions is protected by Article 30. Mr Bhattacharya himself conceded in the same breath that the Constitution has given missionary schools the opportunity to propagate their religion. He cannot praise the Constitution in one sentence and promise to override it in the next. A party president has no power to "not let the school run". Only due process can do that, and due process requires evidence he has refused to produce.

And what are we to make of "no matter how big the force is"? Whose force? The police's? The party's? The mob's? A leader billed as the "moderate face" of his party should not need to be asked what such language invites.

The Law Already Exists. Use It.

Here the facts are not in dispute, and they cut against Mr Bhattacharya's theatre rather than for it. Conversion through coercion, fraud, misrepresentation or inducement is illegal. The Supreme Court, in Rev. Stainislaus v. State of Madhya Pradesh in 1977, upheld state laws against conversion by force, fraud or inducement. The Christian bodies of Bengal do not dispute any of it.

The real dispute is about proof and process. A genuine complaint goes to the police. The police register an FIR. An investigation follows, and then a court. At no stage in that chain does a political leader get to convict a community from a stage, and at no stage does a self-appointed crowd get to substitute for a magistrate.

The Bangya Christya Pariseba's co-founding state secretary, Herod Mullick, put the real problem squarely. No investigation is taking place, he said, while people take the law into their own hands, attack churches and raise conversion allegations, and nobody stops them. That is the scandal. Not the schools. The silence.

The Real Atrocities: Who Is Actually Under Attack?

Mr Bhattacharya wants Bengal to believe that the majority is under siege from a tiny minority. Christians account for 0.72 per cent of the state's population in the 2011 Census. A community of fewer than one in a hundred is accused of overwhelming the other ninety-nine. The arithmetic alone should have given him pause.

Now look at the record he chose to ignore.

A dossier compiled by multiple Christian bodies, reported by this newspaper on November 9, documents what the India Hate Lab counted as 60 distinct cases since May 4: 52 coordinated raids on private prayer assemblies and domestic house churches, and eight violent mob attacks, including physical assault. According to the researchers, perpetrators routinely crash Sunday services on the pretext of demanding identification documents, accuse congregants of forced conversion, vandalise crosses and burn Bibles. Victims and fact-finding delegations have repeatedly named the RSS, the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, the Bajrang Dal, the Hindu Jagran Manch and the Anjani-Putra Sena. These are allegations which those organisations are free to answer, and the proper place to test them is a court of law.

The pattern is not confined to prayer halls. The dossier records burial rights being denied. It records unannounced administrative visits in September to historic Christian institutions after unverified social-media campaigns accused them of proselytisation. At a seven-hour People's Tribunal on November 2, victims from South 24-Parganas, North 24-Parganas, Howrah, East Midnapore and West Midnapore described home attacks, destroyed life savings and the outraging of women's modesty. Reporting elsewhere describes intruders at a September gathering in Panskura invoking a "New Bengal" in which, they said, conversion would no longer be tolerated.

The Pariseba had earlier told the state that it counted 26 incidents in three months and that only 11 FIRs followed. Christian leaders say none was properly investigated. In one reported case, police allegedly stood by during a mob action and then arrested the pastor himself on a charge of conducting conversion rites. The victim became the accused.

The voices who sat through the tribunal were not fringe activists. Jawhar Sircar, the former Prasar Bharati chief, spoke of the despair of hearing case after case of helpless Christians attacked, and of a police force too eager to curry favour. Aakar Patel warned that majoritarian violence left unchecked by the state eventually fractures a whole society. John Dayal, a veteran rights activist, said he had never seen such intensity, viciousness and impunity in a pluralist, inclusive state like Bengal.

This is the hooliganism that Mr Bhattacharya's silence protects: hooligans who have appointed themselves prosecutor, judge and executioner, and who make "conversion" the password that unlocks any church door.

When a Rally Speech Becomes a Licence

The link between the stage and the street is not hard to see. The vigilantes' favourite pretext is the allegation of forced conversion, offered without proof. Mr Bhattacharya's speech offered the same allegation, in the same form, without proof, from a far more powerful platform. At the same time in Mr Bhattacharya's own framing: he said that missionaries may propagate their faith voluntarily and that he is not against any religion. What a double-speaking!

One should know how the governing regime thinks too. Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari said on October 4 that his government will act against forced conversion. Supporters argue that coercive conversion is a real concern that deserves scrutiny, particularly in tribal and poor areas. Added to it, an RSS spokesperson has denied the charges on attacks on Christian institutes and Churches,  and said Christian schools have adequate security.

When the president of the ruling party tells "guardians" to rise against an unnamed school, the hooligan at the back of the crowd does not hear a call for an inquiry. He hears permission. That is why the CPI(M)'s Sujan Chakraborty called the remarks criminal incitement over a baseless allegation, and why the Pariseba, in a restrained statement, called such generalisation "deeply irresponsible, condemnable, and dangerous". It asked, in the same statement, for action against vigilante groups that vandalise peaceful prayer meetings.

Even within the ranks of those sympathetic to the government, there is discomfort. A minister quoted by The Federal has said that incidents of forced conversion, if any, should go to the administration for legal action, and that nobody should take the law into their own hands. Mr Bhattacharya should have said the same on Sunday. He did not.

A Community of Builders, Not Subversives

Bengal's missionary schools and colleges have taught generations of children of every faith, and the great majority of their students were never Christian. As a columnist in ThePrint noted, many ministers in BJP-led governments were themselves educated in such institutions, and many send their children abroad to Christian-majority countries. The faith of those students was not taken from them. The institutions are not "conversion factories".

The West Bengal Association of Christian Schools and the Pariseba have pointed out that, over more than two centuries, these institutions have expanded opportunity especially for the marginalised and the poor. When those same schools felt threatened, they did not threaten anyone in return. They approached the state human rights commission. They asked to meet the RSS leadership. A five-member Pariseba delegation sat down with the RSS state head on November 5. That is how a community with nothing to hide, and everything to lose, behaves.

Contrast that conduct with a leader who will not give a name, will not file a complaint, and has chosen the language of ultimatums.

What an Honest Leader Would Do

Mr Bhattacharya has a simple choice, and it is a choice between accountability and slander.

First, he should place before the police and the education department, within a reasonable time, the names of the institutions he alleges are engaged in forced conversion, harbour a Pakistani flag or discriminate against saffron-wearing women, along with whatever evidence he holds. If he has it, the law will take its course. If he does not, he should say so.

Second, if he cannot or will not produce proof, he owes Bengal's Christians, and its teachers and students, an unconditional public apology, and a withdrawal of the blanket charge that missionary schools are engaged in "anti-India activities".

Third, he should disown his own threat to stand at a school gate, and promise that no party worker will do so.

Fourth, he should condemn by name the vigilante raids on prayer meetings, and demand of his own government what the Pariseba has asked: FIRs registered, perpetrators arrested, places of worship protected.

The Christians of Bengal are not asking for favours. They are asking for what any citizen of a constitutional republic may ask: that accusations be backed by evidence, that grievances be settled by law and not by mobs, and that the state protect them rather than the people who attack them.

A politician who calls himself a moderate must prove it when moderation is hard, not when it is easy. Samik Bhattacharya made a serious accusation against a whole community on Sunday. He has one honourable way out. Name the school, show the proof, or say sorry.

Friday, September 18, 2026

Beyond the Couch: Why Psychology Must Serve, Not Sovereign, in Seminary Formation

 

A critical response to “Not Every Priest Should Be Allowed Near a Seminary Formation Team”





Introduction

The article (certainly with AI assistance!), found on WhatsApp titled “Not Every Priest Should Be Allowed Near a Seminary Formation Team” uploaded by Sr. Jaisy SMI,  is right about several things. Harshness passed off as discipline is real, and so are formators who read every struggle as a lack of vocation. Its closing line, however, gives the game away: “competence in understanding the human person must become the essential part of priestly formation itself.” Its remedy is more training in psychology, pedagogy, counselling and emotional intelligence, and it never mentions grace, prayer, discernment, the Holy Spirit or the mystery of a vocation.

The text also reads as machine-assembled. It repeats the same thesis in its second-last and last paragraphs, leans on stock analogies (pilots, doctors, canon lawyers), and offers rhetorical triplets (“Not every silence is humility…”) in place of argument. The article claims “human beings are not machines,” yet it proposes a formation that is largely technical: acquire the right competencies and the seminarian’s “problem” will be solved.

This response does not reject the human sciences. It argues that they are servants of formation, not its foundation. A seminarian is a mystery before he is a case, and the Church’s own documents say so.

1. What the Article Gets Right, and Where the Church Agrees

The Church has never taught that formators may ignore the human person. Pastores Dabo Vobis insists that “in order that his ministry may be humanly as credible and acceptable as possible, it is necessary that the priest should mould his human personality in such a way that it becomes a bridge and not an obstacle for others in their meeting with Jesus Christ” (John Paul II, Pastores Dabo Vobis [PDV], 1992, n. 43).

Ratio Fundamentalis Institutionis Sacerdotalis (RFIS, Congregation for the Clergy, 2016) likewise treats human formation as “the necessary foundation” of the whole edifice, and it takes maturity, affectivity and freedom seriously (cf. RFIS, nn. 89–100). The Congregation for Catholic Education’s Guidelines for the Use of Psychology in the Admission and Formation of Candidates for the Priesthood (2008) also permits a prudent use of psychological expertise where it is needed.

So the article’s concern is legitimate. The disagreement is over ordering and proportion, and over what a formator is fundamentally for.

2. The Article’s Central Flaw: A Reduced Anthropology

The article’s opening sentence treats the seminarian as a bundle of “emotions, fears, family wounds, psychological struggles, temperamental differences… hormonal realities.” All of these are real. But the list is missing the centre of the person: the soul made for God, called by name, and marked by grace.

The Second Vatican Council teaches that “only in the mystery of the incarnate Word does the mystery of man take on light” (Gaudium et Spes, 1965, n. 22). Man is not finally explained by psychology or any other science. He is explained by Christ, and he remains a mystery even after every diagnostic category has been applied. Some consequences follow from this.

•         A vocation is not a personality profile. It is a call, and its origin is God, not the seminarian’s temperament (cf. PDV, n. 35).

•         Grace is not reducible to emotional health. The saints include the anxious, the scrupulous, the introverted and the wounded. Formation must not treat a woundedness that grace is already transfiguring as though it were a defect to be managed.

•         Mystery cannot be “solved.” The article’s language of understanding, perceiving and mastering the human mind slides into a managerial mindset. The Church asks formators instead to stand before something sacred.

Pope Francis expresses this posture well: the art of accompaniment “teaches us to remove our sandals before the sacred ground of the other” (Evangelii Gaudium, 2013, n. 169). One removes one’s sandals before a mystery. One does not do so before a case file.

3. The Missing Centre: Spiritual Formation as the “Core”

The article never uses the word “spiritual” except as a pejorative (“pious vocabulary,” “spiritual slogans”). The Church’s documents give it a very different place.

•         Optatam Totius teaches that seminarians must be trained “to live in intimate and unceasing union with the Father through His Son Jesus Christ in the Holy Spirit” (Vatican II, Optatam Totius [OT], 1965, n. 8).

•         Pastores Dabo Vobis describes spiritual formation as “the core which unifies and gives life to his being a priest and his acting as a priest” (PDV, n. 45).

•         RFIS places the spiritual dimension at the heart of the formative process, alongside the human, intellectual and pastoral dimensions, and it grounds all four in discipleship and configuration to Christ the Good Shepherd (cf. RFIS, nn. 28–34, 101–115).

The four dimensions are meant to be integrated, and none of them is meant to become the “essential part” that governs the rest. An article that elevates the human dimension above the others has quietly reversed the Church’s order.

4. Psychology Is an Auxiliary Tool, Not the Norm

The Church has been explicit here, and the article ignores it. The 2008 Guidelines on psychology repeatedly stress that psychological expertise is an aid to the discernment carried out by the Church’s own formators, and that it cannot replace spiritual direction, the judgement of the formation team, or the discernment of the bishop or superior. The Guidelines also caution that the psychological approach must be consonant with a Christian anthropology, since some schools of psychology rest on assumptions about the human person that Catholic teaching cannot accept.

This point matters. The article speaks of “Modern Psychology” as if it were one unified and neutral science. In fact:

•         Psychology contains competing schools with different (sometimes contradictory) views of human nature, freedom, sin and sexuality.

•         Some of these views treat guilt, self-denial or obedience as pathologies, which is incompatible with the Gospel.

•         A formator trained without a robust Christian anthropology may import these assumptions uncritically and end up “healing” what the Church would call sanctification.

The safeguard is a formator whose primary formation is spiritual and theological, who draws on the human sciences critically and with humility, and who knows where their competence ends. Credentialing a formator mainly by his psychology training turns the safeguard upside down.

5. The Analogies Fail

The article argues that the Church trains canon lawyers, doctors and pilots before letting them practise, so formators need psychological training. The analogies are weaker than they look.

•         Lawyers, doctors and pilots exercise technical skills. A formator’s primary work is spiritual paternity, the accompaniment of a soul toward God. The proper comparison is not with a technician but with a father, a shepherd, a spiritual master.

•         The Church’s saints were formators too. St. John Vianney, St. Francis de Sales and St. Ignatius (who wrote the Spiritual Exercises before modern psychology existed) all formed souls with extraordinary wisdom. They did so through prayer, discernment of spirits, and long personal holiness.

•         The formator forms by who he is. RFIS speaks of formators as those who “accompany” and bear witness through their own lives (cf. RFIS, nn. 129–139, on the formation of formators). A seminarian learns the priesthood chiefly by seeing it lived.

The article would ask whether a formator has the right credentials. The Church asks first whether he is a man of prayer, faithful to his own priesthood, and able to be a credible witness.

6. Formation Is a Work of Art, Not Only a Method

Pope Francis, addressing seminarians and novices in 2013, warned against two opposite errors: formation as rigid policing and formation as a purely technical exercise. He said, in effect, that formation is “a work of art, not a police action,” and that the aim is to form hearts (Francis, Address to Seminarians, Novices and Those Discerning a Vocation, 6 July 2013). It is a fine warning against harshness.

But notice the phrase “work of art.” An artist is not a technician following a protocol. He works with something given, and he cooperates with a design that is not his own. In priestly formation, that design is God’s. The formator is a collaborator with the Holy Spirit, not the engineer of a finished product.

The article’s “systemic” mentality (train the formator, fix the pipeline, produce emotionally balanced priests) forgets this. Formation is not a factory, and the Church says as much when she calls it “a continuous journey of discipleship” (cf. RFIS, nn. 3, 57; PDV, n. 70).

7. What Seminarians Need “Much More” Of

Seminarians need competent, humane formators. But they need more than competence, and the Church’s documents point to what this “more” includes.

•         Formators who are men of prayer. A formator who does not pray cannot lead others into prayer, whatever his degrees.

•         Serious spiritual direction. The Church requires it and treats the spiritual director as central to formation (cf. PDV, n. 40; RFIS, nn. 44–48, 107–109).

•         A sacramental life. Formation is nourished by the Eucharist, Reconciliation, the Liturgy of the Hours and Marian devotion, which heal and shape the person in ways no technique reaches (cf. PDV, n. 48).

•         Discernment of spirits. The tradition of Ignatius, Teresa and John of the Cross teaches how to read consolation, desolation, temptation and the movements of grace. This is a spiritual skill that psychology does not replace.

•         A contemplative gaze. Formators should look at a seminarian’s struggles with faith as well as with insight. What looks like a psychological knot may be a stage of the dark night, and what looks like a spiritual failing may need clinical help. Only a formator who is both spiritually and humanly formed can tell the difference.

•         Fatherhood. PDV describes the priest’s ministry as spiritual fatherhood. A seminarian needs a father before he needs an evaluator.

8. A Balanced Proposal

Rather than the article’s “essential part,” a more faithful formulation would be the following.

•         Integration, not substitution. The four dimensions of formation (human, spiritual, intellectual, pastoral) grow together (RFIS, nn. 27–34).

•         Selection of formators by holiness first. PDV insists that formators be chosen with great care, as men of sound doctrine, pastoral experience and spiritual depth (cf. PDV, n. 66).

•         Psychology as consultant. Qualified, morally sound and Christian-anthropology-aware professionals should be available for referral, as the 2008 Guidelines provide, but the formation team retains the responsibility to discern.

•         Basic human formation for all formators. Every formator should have a working grasp of human development, listening skills and the dynamics of accompaniment. This is reasonable, but it is a complement to spiritual competence and not the criterion.

•         Continuing formation of formators. This should include retreats, spiritual direction and theological renewal alongside human-science training.

Conclusion

The article warns rightly against formators who mistake trauma for rebellion or punish what they do not understand. But it offers a diagnosis and a cure that are both too small. The diagnosis is that formators lack psychological training, and the cure is more of it. The Church’s own teaching says the deeper need is for formators who are men of God, who see the seminarian as a mystery to be reverenced and a son to be fathered, and who use the human sciences as instruments in the service of grace.

Man is, as Gaudium et Spes teaches, a mystery illumined only in Christ. A formation that forgets this may produce priests who are well-adjusted, emotionally literate and professionally competent, and still leave them without the interior life that alone sustains a priest for forty years. The Church needs priests who are human and holy, and formators who can say to a seminarian, with St. Paul, that “it is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me” (Gal 2:20).

Note: Quotations are from standard English translations.

Here is the text of the original article: NOT EVERY PRIEST SHOULD BE ALLOWED NEAR A SEMINARY FORMATION TEAM.

In this century, it has become dangerously outdated to assume that every priest automatically qualifies to become a seminary formator simply because he wears a cassock, has a loud voice at conferences, or can quote Latin documents from memory. Human beings are not machines assembled with spiritual slogans.

A seminarian is a complex human person carrying emotions, fears, family wounds, psychological struggles, temperamental differences, social pressures, intellectual anxieties, hormonal realities, and personal history. Forming such a person requires more than pious vocabulary and disciplinary aggression disguised as “formation.”

It is becoming increasingly necessary that priests appointed as seminary formators undergo rigorous training in Modern Psychology, Human Development, Guidance and Counselling, Emotional Intelligence, and Pastoral Accompaniment before being entrusted with the delicate task of forming future priests.

Not every silence is humility. Not every extrovert is unserious. Not every reserved seminarian is proud. Not every struggling student is lazy. And not every emotionally wounded young man needs more punishment delivered with holy water.

Unfortunately, many formators were trained in environments where every human difficulty was interpreted either as “lack of vocation,” “spiritual weakness,” or “disobedience,” while basic psychological realities were ignored completely. Then years later, we become surprised when some priests carry unresolved emotional instability into ministry.

The truth is that one cannot adequately guide what one does not adequately understand.

The Church trains canon lawyers before allowing them judge cases. She trains doctors before allowing them touch the sick. Pilots are not sent into the air merely because they love aviation. It would therefore be intellectually inconsistent to consider psychological and human-scientific formation unnecessary in the very area where the Church is shaping future priests who will spend their lives dealing with human souls, emotions, crises, families, grief, loneliness, conflict, and moral struggles.

A formator must know theology, yes! but he must also understand the human person standing before him. Otherwise, he may mistake trauma for rebellion, exhaustion for indiscipline, introversion for arrogance, or emotional distress for lack of prayer.

The future of the priesthood will depend not only on how spiritually sound our formators are, but also on how psychologically educated, emotionally mature, intellectually balanced, and humanly perceptive they become.

Monday, July 27, 2026

মঞ্চের রাজনীতি, ধর্মীয় মুখোশ, আর খ্র্রীষ্টান নেতৃত্বের নৈতিক সংকট

 


পশ্চিমবঙ্গের এক রাজনৈতিক সমাবেশে খ্র্রীষ্টান  পাস্টর ও বিশপদের মঞ্চে দাঁড়ানোকে সরল সৌজন্য বা আন্তধর্মীয় সম্প্রীতির নিদর্শন বলে মেনে নেওয়া যায় না। এটি বরং এমন এক দৃশ্য, যেখানে ক্ষমতার কাছাকাছি থাকার লোভ, পরিচয়ের রাজনীতি, আর নৈতিক অবস্থানের ধোঁয়াশা একসঙ্গে মিশে গেছে। যে জোটের অদৃশ্য কিন্তু অনিবার্য ছায়ায় বিজেপি ও আরএসএস দাঁড়িয়ে আছে, সেই জোটের মঞ্চে ধর্মীয় নেতাদের হাসিমুখে দাঁড়ানো—এটা অনেকের কাছে আত্মরক্ষা মনে হতে পারে, কিন্তু সমান সংখ্যক মানুষের কাছে এটি আত্মসমর্পণ। কারণ, যে রাজনৈতিক জোটের কেন্দ্রীয় কাঠামোয় বিজেপি ও আরএসএস অনিবার্যভাবে যুক্ত, সেই জোটের রাজনৈতিক চরিত্র সমগ্র দেশকে ধর্মীয় মেরুকরণ, সন্দেহ এবং নির্বাচনী লাভের রাজনীতিতে ঠেলে দিয়েছে—এ কথা নতুন করে প্রমাণের প্রয়োজন নেই। এমন একটি মঞ্চে খ্র্রীষ্টান  ধর্মগুরুদের উপস্থিতি তাই স্বাভাবিক ধর্মীয় অংশগ্রহণ নয়; বরং তা এক গভীর নৈতিক বিভ্রান্তি, যার উত্তর পাওয়া দরকার।

প্রথম প্রশ্নটি সরাসরি: এই পাস্টর ও বিশপরা কার প্রতিনিধিত্ব করছেন? ওইসব খ্র্রীষ্টান  নেতা কি সত্যিই তাঁদের মন্ডলী, তাঁদের বিশ্বাসী সমাজ, এবং তাঁদের ধর্মীয় শৃঙ্খলার প্রতিনিধিত্ব করছেন? তাঁদের অভিষেক, প্রশিক্ষণ, স্বীকৃতি এবং মন্ড্লীগত শৃঙ্খলার বৈধতা কোথায়? নাকি তাঁরা এমন এক পরিচয় নির্মাণ করছেন, যা মাইক, ক্যামেরা, আর রাজনৈতিক হাততালির ওপর দাঁড়িয়ে আছে? যদি তাঁদের অভিষেক, প্রশিক্ষণ, বা চার্চ-স্বীকৃতি স্পষ্ট না হয়, তাহলে তাঁদের “পাস্টর” বা “বিশপ” পরিচয় জনপরিসরে আনা কতটা বৈধ—সেটিও প্রশ্নসাপেক্ষ। যদি তাঁরা সত্যিই প্রতিষ্ঠিত মন্ডলী-শৃঙ্খলার অধীনে দায়িত্বপ্রাপ্ত হন, তাহলে তাঁদের অবস্থান প্রকাশ্যে স্বচ্ছ হওয়া উচিত। আর যদি তাঁরা স্বঘোষিত নেতৃত্বের আড়ালে রাজনৈতিক মঞ্চে নিজেকে প্রতিষ্ঠিত করতে চান, তবে সেটি শুধু নৈতিকভাবে ভুল নয়, বিশ্বাসভঙ্গের শামিল। ধর্মীয় পদবি শুধু একটি নাম নয়; তা দায়িত্ব, শৃঙ্খলা, এবং জবাবদিহির দাবি করে। সেই দাবি যদি না থাকে, তবে মঞ্চে দাঁড়ানোটা হয়ে যায় একটি সাজানো অভিনয়। খ্রীষ্টীয়  নেতৃত্ব কোনো ব্যক্তিগত প্রচার-যন্ত্র নয়। এটি ক্ষমতার কাছে উপস্থিত হয়ে public recognition আদায়ের মাধ্যমও নয়।

আরও উদ্বেগজনক হলো, এই উপস্থিতি কি বিজেপি-শাসিত বা বিজেপি-প্রভাবিত রাজনৈতিক পরিসরের নিরাপদ আশ্রয় খোঁজার কৌশল? তাঁরা কি ক্ষমতার নিরাপদ পাশে দাঁড়াতে চাইছেন? ? বিজেপি-শাসিত বা বিজেপি-প্রভাবিত শাসনব্যবস্থার সঙ্গে ঘনিষ্ঠতা তৈরি করলে হয়তো কিছু প্রশাসনিক সুবিধা, কিছু public visibility, কিছু “সম্মান” পাওয়া যায়। কিন্তু সেই সম্মান কি সত্যিকারের, না কি ভয়ের আবরণে পাওয়া সার্টিফিকেট? পশ্চিমবঙ্গসহ দেশে যখন খ্র্রীষ্টানদের বিরুদ্ধে হামলা, চার্চ ভাঙচুর, প্রার্থনায় বাধা,সামাজিক নিপীড়নের এবং প্রশাসনিক অসহযোগিতার অভিযোগ উঠছে, তখন কিছু ধর্মীয় নেতা ক্ষমতাশালী শাসনের ছায়ায় দাঁড়িয়ে নিজেকে সুরক্ষিত করতে চাইছেন কি না—এই প্রশ্ন অবধারিতভাবে ওঠে। যদি তাই হয়, তবে তা নেতৃত্ব নয়; তা সুবিধাবাদ। অভিযোগ উঠে আসে, তখন ক্ষমতার পাশে দাঁড়িয়ে থাকা কিছু ধর্মীয় নেতার ছবি এক ধরনের আত্মরক্ষার ছদ্মবেশ ছাড়া আর কিছু মনে হয় না।

এখানেই সবচেয়ে কুৎসিত সত্যটা সামনে আসে। যে রাজনৈতিক জোটকে ঘিরে বারবার communal division, propaganda, এবং ভোট-ধ্রুবীকরণের অভিযোগ উঠেছে, তার মঞ্চে দাঁড়িয়ে কোনো খ্র্রীষ্টান  নেতা যদি নিজের সম্প্রদায়ের পক্ষে কথা বলেন, তবে সেটি তখনই বিশ্বাসযোগ্য হয়, যখন তিনি একই সঙ্গে সেই জোটের বিভাজনমূলক রাজনীতির বিরুদ্ধেও স্পষ্ট অবস্থান নেন। কিন্তু যদি তিনি কেবল মঞ্চের সাজসজ্জা হয়ে থাকেন, তবে তিনি সম্প্রদায়ের কণ্ঠ নন—তিনি প্রচারণার উপকরণ। আর সুবিধাবাদের ধর্মীয় রূপ সবচেয়ে বিপজ্জনক, কারণ তা বিশ্বাসীদের চোখে আধ্যাত্মিকতা হিসেবে ধরা পড়ে, অথচ ভিতরে থাকে ভীতু সমঝোতা।

এই মঞ্চে “সংখ্যালঘু সুরক্ষা” বা “সমতার” বুলি যতই উচ্চারিত হোক, বাস্তবতা অন্য কথা বলে। বিজেপি-আরএসএস-ঘনিষ্ঠ রাজনৈতিক ভাষ্য দীর্ঘদিন ধরেই সমাজে বিভাজন, সন্দেহ এবং ধর্মীয় উসকানিকে স্বাভাবিক করে তুলেছে। যে রাজনৈতিক বাতাবরণ একটি দেশকে “আমরা” আর “ওরা” ভাগে খণ্ডিত করে, সেই পরিবেশে দাঁড়িয়ে ধর্মীয় নেতার আশীর্বাদ দেওয়া মানে কেবল নিরীহ উপস্থিতি নয়—তা এক ধরনের বৈধতা প্রদান। আর সেই বৈধতাই পরে প্রচারযন্ত্রে ব্যবহার হয়। মঞ্চে একজন পাস্টর বা বিশপ থাকলেই যদি খ্র্রীষ্টান  সমাজের সমর্থন বলে প্রচার করা যায়, তবে সেটি প্রতারণার রাজনৈতিক কৌশল ছাড়া আর কী?

খ্র্রীষ্টান  সমাজের পক্ষ থেকে এখানে আরও কঠোর জবাবদিহি দাবি করা উচিত। এই লোকগুলো কারা? তাঁদের মন্ডলী কোথায়? তাঁদের অধ্যক্ষ কারা? তাঁদের ordination কোথা থেকে? তাঁদের training, accountability, ecclesial discipline কোথায়? কোন মন্ডলী তাঁদের এই ধরনের রাজনৈতিক মঞ্চে যাওয়ার অনুমোদন দিয়েছে? কোন সিনড, কোন ডায়োসিস, কোন ফেলোশিপ, কোন চার্চ কাউন্সিল তাঁদের প্রতিনিধিত্ব স্বীকার করেছে? নাকি তাঁরা কেবল ক্যামেরার সামনে দাঁড়িয়ে ধর্মীয় পোশাকের মর্যাদাকে রাজনৈতিক শোভায় পরিণত করছেন? নাকি তাঁরা কেবল এমন কিছু স্বঘোষিত আধ্যাত্মিক মুখ, যারা ধর্মীয় পোশাককে রাজনৈতিক পাসপোর্টে পরিণত করেছেন? আজকের দিনে ধর্মীয় পরিচয় ব্যবহার করে ক্ষমতার টেবিলে জায়গা নেওয়া খুব সহজ। কঠিন হলো সেই পরিচয়ের নৈতিক পরীক্ষা পাস করা। আর সেখানেই এইসব নেতার দুর্বলতা ধরা পড়ে। যে কেউ বাইবেল ধরে মঞ্চে উঠলেই তিনি যাজক হয়ে যান না। আর যে কেউ বিশপের পোশাক পরলেই তাঁর নৈতিক কর্তৃত্ব জন্মায় না। নেতৃত্বের প্রথম শর্ত হলো বিশ্বাসযোগ্যতা। আর বিশ্বাসযোগ্যতা আসে স্বচ্ছতা, শৃঙ্খলা এবং সত্যনিষ্ঠা থেকে।

সবচেয়ে কষ্টদায়ক বিষয় হলো, এই ধরনের উপস্থিতি নিপীড়িত খ্র্রীষ্টানদের ক্ষতকে আরও জটিল করে তোলে। যারা চার্চ আক্রমণ, প্রার্থনায় বাধা, সামাজিক হেনস্তা, বা প্রশাসনিক অবহেলার ভেতর দিয়ে যাচ্ছে, তারা রাজনৈতিক মঞ্চে দাঁড়িয়ে থাকা ধর্মীয় নেতাদের দেখে প্রশ্ন করবেই—তোমরা কি সত্যিই আমাদের পক্ষে, না কি ক্ষমতার কাছে নিজেদের পক্ষে? এই প্রশ্নকে অবজ্ঞা করা যায় না। কারণ নিপীড়িত মানুষের কাছে নেতৃত্বের মানে কেবল ভাষণ নয়; নেতৃত্বের মানে সাহস, স্পষ্টতা এবং সত্যের পাশে দাঁড়ানো। যাঁরা সত্যিই নিপীড়িত খ্র্রীষ্টানদের পাশে দাঁড়াতে চান, তাঁরা জনতার সামনে ছবি তুলে নয়, নীরব বিপদের সময়ে সাহস দেখিয়ে প্রমাণ দেবেন। তাঁরা ধর্মীয় স্বাধীনতা, উপাসনার অধিকার, এবং মন্ডলীর নিরাপত্তার প্রশ্নে অনর্গল, অদ্ভুত ভদ্রতা নয়—স্পষ্টতা দেখাবেন। কিন্তু মঞ্চে গিয়ে রাজনৈতিক নেতাদের সঙ্গে হাত মেলানো, তারপর “সম্প্রীতি” ও “ঐক্য”র বুলি আওড়ানো—এটা leadership নয়; এটা packaging. আর একবার packaging শুরু হলে, faith-এর জায়গায় চলে আসে branding।

এখানে একটি নীতিগত কথা বলা দরকার: যদি কোনো ধর্মীয় নেতা সত্যিই সংখ্যালঘু অধিকার, উপাসনার স্বাধীনতা এবং আইনি সুরক্ষার জন্য রাজনৈতিক মঞ্চ ব্যবহার করেন, তবে তা তখনই গ্রহণযোগ্য, যখন তিনি একই সঙ্গে ক্ষমতাসীন শক্তির বিভাজনমূলক চরিত্রের সমালোচনাও করেন। কিন্তু যদি তিনি কেবল ছবি তোলেন, মঞ্চ ভাগ করেন, আর ভাষণে “ঐক্য” বলেন—তবে সেটি নৈতিক অবস্থান নয়; সেটি রাজনৈতিক আলোকচিত্র। এবং ধর্মীয় নেতৃত্বকে আলোকচিত্রে সীমাবদ্ধ করা মানে  বিশ্ব-খ্রীষ্ট মন্ডলীকে শূন্য প্রতীকে পরিণত করা। বিভাজনের রাজনীতি যখন সমাজের ভিতরকার সম্পর্ককে বিষাক্ত করে তোলে, তখন ধর্মীয় নেতার কাজ হওয়া উচিত সেই বিষের বিরুদ্ধে দাঁড়ানো, না যে-শক্তি বিষ ছড়াচ্ছে তার পাশে ছবি দেওয়া। কিন্তু এই মঞ্চে দাঁড়িয়ে কিছু নেতা যেন উল্টো বার্তা দিচ্ছেন—“আমরা আছি, আমাদের ভুল বুঝবেন না, আমাদের মেনে নিন।” কেন? কারণ হয়তো তাঁরা বিশ্বাস করেন, বৃহৎ শক্তির পাশে থাকলে ছোট মানুষের নিরাপত্তা বাড়বে। কিন্তু বাস্তবে অনেক সময় তা ঘটে না। বরং এমন সম্পর্ক ধর্মীয় নেতৃত্বকে দুর্বল করে, আর সাধারণ বিশ্বাসীদের চোখে তাঁদের বিশ্বাসযোগ্যতাকেও ক্ষয় করে।

সুতরাং, এখানে সহানুভূতিশীল ব্যাখ্যা যতই দেওয়া হোক, প্রশ্নগুলো থেকে মুক্তি নেই। এই উপস্থিতি কি নৈতিক সাহস, না সুবিধাবাদ? এটি কি সম্প্রদায়ের স্বার্থে কৌশল, না ক্ষমতার সঙ্গে নিরাপদ মিশে যাওয়ার চেষ্টা? এটি কি সত্যিকার প্রতিনিধিত্ব, না public recognition-এর ক্ষুধা? এবং সবচেয়ে গুরুত্বপূর্ণ, এইসব খ্র্রীষ্টান  নেতা কি সত্যিই নিজেদের মন্ডলীর সামনে জবাবদিহি করবেন, নাকি রাজনৈতিক মঞ্চের হর্ষধ্বনিতেই নিজেদের পরিচয় বৈধ বলে ধরে নেবেন? অতএব, প্রশ্নের উত্তর কঠোর হলেও স্পষ্ট: হ্যাঁ, এই উপস্থিতি সন্দেহের জন্ম দেয়। হ্যাঁ, এর মধ্যে public recognition এবং রাজনৈতিক সুবিধা-অন্বেষণের গন্ধ আছে। হ্যাঁ, BJP-শাসিত বা BJP-প্রভাবিত রাজনীতির নিরাপদ পাশে দাঁড়ানোর চেষ্টা মনে হওয়া অস্বাভাবিক নয়। এবং হ্যাঁ, এইসব ধর্মীয় নেতাদের পরিচয়, বৈধতা, প্রশিক্ষণ ও প্রতিনিধিত্ব নিয়ে নিরপেক্ষ তদন্ত হওয়া প্রয়োজন। খ্র্রীষ্টান  সমাজের উচিত আবেগ নয়, জবাবদিহি দাবি করা।

যে সময় দেশ বিভাজনের রাজনীতিতে ক্লান্ত, সে সময়ে ধর্মীয় নেতৃত্বের কাজ হওয়া উচিত সত্যের পক্ষে, আক্রান্তদের পাশে এবং নৈতিক সাহসের সঙ্গে দাঁড়ানো। রাজনীতি যদি ধর্মকে ব্যবহার করে, সেটি নতুন কিছু নয়। কিন্তু ধর্মীয় নেতৃত্ব যদি নিজেই রাজনীতির সেবা করতে শুরু করে, তবে বিপদ আরও গভীর। তখন মঞ্চে থাকে ধর্মের নাম, আর ভিতরে কাজ করে ক্ষমতার হিসাব। এটাই এই ঘটনার সবচেয়ে বিস্ফোরক সত্য। ক্ষমতার মঞ্চে দাঁড়িয়ে ছবি তোলা নয়। আর যদি কেউ সেটিকেই নেতৃত্ব বলে চালাতে চান, তবে তাঁদের নাম আধ্যাত্মিকতার ইতিহাসে নয়, সুবিধাবাদের তালিকায় লেখা হবে।

Tuesday, June 2, 2026

Fr. C. L. MATHEW, SDB: 12 June 1943 — 30 May 2026


With deep sorrow and grateful remembrance, the Salesian Province of Kolkata announces the passing away of Fr. Chiriyankandath Mathew, SDB, who died on 30 May 2026 at 11:00 PM at Don Bosco Welfare Centre, Azimganj. He was 83 years old. A Requiem Mass was celebrated at Don Bosco Provincial House, Kolkata, on 1 June 2026 at 6:30 PM, and on 4 June 2026 at 2:00 PM his mortal remains will be laid to rest at Bandel Basilica. Kindly pray for the repose of his soul. Fr. C. L. Mathew, a beloved Salesian priest and devoted servant of God, has spent a lifetime in humble service to the Church, young people, and the wider community. His death leaves a deep void among confreres, parishioners, and the many laypeople whose lives he touched.

Born on 12 June 1943 in Wadakkancherry, Kerala, Fr. Mathew gave his life generously in the Salesian vocation. He made his First Profession on 24 April 1964 in Shillong, his Perpetual Profession on 9 April 1970 in Sonada, Darjeeling, and was ordained a priest on 22 December 1973 in Trichur, Kerala. From that time until his death, he lived as a faithful Salesian priest, educator, pastor, and companion of the young.

Life and ministry

Fr. Mathew was a Salesian through and through. Over the course of his priestly ministry he served in multiple roles: rector, principal, parish priest, assistant parish priest, bursar, confessor, and spiritual guide and a barefoot counselor.  In every ministry he exercised a practical, service-oriented pastoral style. He was widely known by many common faithful as a “helper-priest” who favored simple living and warm, accessible pastoral care. Colleagues and parishioners alike remember him as a man without malice or judgment, always ready to listen and to help.

Fr. Mathew served in a wide range of apostolates with steadfast commitment and simplicity. His assignments included Assistant Principal at DB Technical School, Park Circus (1974–1976); Assistant Principal, Don Bosco School, Park Circus (1976–1979); Assistant Principal, Don Bosco School, Liluah (1979–1982); Bursar, Don Bosco School, Azimganj (1982–1985); Principal, Don Bosco School, Bandel (1985–1989); Rector, Don Bosco, Krishnagar (1989–1995); Parish Priest, St. Albert’s Home, Monsada (1995–1998); Bursar, Don Bosco School, Liluah (1998–1999); Parish Priest, Catholic Church, Kalyani (1999–2006); Bursar and Assistant Director, DB SERI, Mirpara (2006–2007); Rector, DB SERI, Mirpara (2007–2010); Bursar, Don Bosco Welfare Centre, Azimganj (2010–2014); Assistant Director, Don Bosco Ashalayam (2014–2016); Assistant Parish Priest and Confessor, Don Bosco, Krishnagar (2016–2018); Bursar, Don Bosco Vidyaniketan, Kalyani (2018–2020); and Confessor, Don Bosco Welfare Centre, Azimganj (2020–2026)

In every mission entrusted to him, Fr. Mathew showed himself to be practical, attentive and deeply service-oriented. He carried out his responsibilities with quiet efficiency and a pastoral heart, always placing people before procedure and service before self. He was widely known as a “people’s priest” who lived simply, spoke plainly, and approached everyone with warmth and without judgment.

Care for the young

Fr. Mathew had a special love for young people, especially the boys in boarding homes and institutions under his care. He believed in accompaniment, formation through presence, and the quiet power of encouragement. Many former boarders and students remember him as patient, approachable, and steady—someone who listened, advised, and made time for them. His presence gave confidence to many who were still finding their way in life.

 Healing and practical concern

Fr. Mathew often self-medicated and, out of pastoral concern, recommended these treatments to confreres and parishioners, who came to him for help. Beyond spiritual accompaniment, Fr. Mathew took a pastoral interest in the physical well‑being of those he served. He was also known for his pragmatic interest in traditional and natural medicine. Confident in DeChane (a century‑old herbal and alternative medicine tradition founded by the DeSouza family, to which Fr. Cyril D'souza belongs, in Hyderabad in 1917, a proprietary line of formulations blending Ayurveda, Homeopathy, and modern pharmacology)  and  also Ayurveda and Homeopathy independently. Fr. Mathew often used these treatments for himself and recommended them, out of pastoral concern, to confreres, parishioners, and lay people who came to him for help. He was remembered not only as a priest but also as someone who cared for bodily well-being with the same concern he showed for spiritual growth. His approach to healing was consistent with his practical, compassionate way of tending to bodily as well as spiritual needs.His readiness to share remedies, advice, and time earned him the affectionate reputation of being a healer in both body and spirit.

In a similar spirit of service, he helped many young couples who were facing difficulties in begetting children, offering them encouragement, practical suggestions and prayerful support while accompanying them with sensitivity and compassion.

 Personality and interests

Fr. Mathew was a man of conversation, thought, and quiet pleasures. He enjoyed logical discussion and took delight in playing chess and other simple pastimes. These interests reflected a personality that was thoughtful, disciplined, and calm. He combined intellectual seriousness with humility, and his ordinary pleasures were marked by the same simplicity that characterized his priestly life.

Memories from confreres

The confreres of the Province of Kolkata have expressed deep affection and gratitude for his life and witness:

  • “Dear Fr. CL Mathew, you will be remembered by us as an Educationist and a Pastor after the heart of Don Bosco! Adieu and pray for us from heaven!” — Fr. Tomy Mathew, SDB
  • “You were very affable, concerned to sick confrers and people in general and supply medicine too taking nothing in return. You will be remembered for your kindness.” — Br. Theophil, SDB
  • “We have lost a loving and effective pastor, a concerned social worker, a physician with medicine and suggestions for good health.” — Fr. P. M. Mathew, SDB
  • “Will always cherish the memories of Bandel when you were principal and I was a practical trainee.” — Fr. Tomy Augustine, SDB
  • “I had lived with him in my community at Kalyani years ago. I have fresh memories of him since just 4 months ago I had met and chatted with him in DB Azimganj!” — Fr. E. A. Thomas, SDB
  • “Many children in Ashalayam remember him fondly. His gentle and encouraging presence is well remembered.” — Fr. C. J. George, SDB
  • “Good Lord, accept Fr. C. L. Mathew, your good servant through whom you continued your salvific works...” — Sanjla Babu, SDB
  • “I missed Fr. C L Mathew as he left for eternal reward in heaven. He was so loving and caring to me when I was in Don Bosco Azimganj. It was he who gave me medicine for kidney stone during Corona pandemic when I was suffering during those days. He helped all the poor people with medicine and counseling. May God grant him eternal rest. Amen” – Fr. Xavier Lakra SDB

 Funeral arrangements

A Requiem Mass was celebrated on 1 June 2026 at 6:30 PM in the Provincial House Chapel, Kolkata. His mortal remains will be laid to rest at Bandel Basilica on 4 June 2026 at 2:00 PM. Further details regarding memorial services, if any, will be communicated by the Province.

How to Remember and Pray

Those who wish to mourn and give thanks for Fr. Mathew’s life are encouraged to pray for the repose of his soul, to offer Masses or personal prayers in his memory, and to support one another in this time of loss. In memory of his lifelong service to youth and families, donations to Salesian educational or boarding ministries may be made in his name if desired.

Closing tribute

Fr. C. L. Mathew will be remembered as a devoted Salesian, a loving and effective pastor, a trusted confessor, a concerned social worker, and a healer in both body and spirit. He embodied the Salesian spirit in a simple, pastoral, and practical way. Beloved as a Priest-guide, a spiritual companion, and respected as an educator and social worker, he leaves behind a legacy of quiet charity and steadfast service. He served with humility, kindness, and practical wisdom, leaving behind a legacy of quiet charity and faithful priestly ministry. He will be remembered for his pastoral care, his calm presence, and his unwavering commitment to serving others without spite.

We have lost a loving and effective pastor, a concerned social worker, a physician with medicine and suggestions for good health and sound spirit. We entrust him now to God’s merciful love and commend his soul to the prayers of the Church. May the Lord reward his life of generous dedication and grant him eternal rest.

May he rest in peace.

-          Soroj Mullick SDB, 1st June 2026, Nitika DB, Kol-15 

NAME THE SCHOOL, SHOW THE PROOF: SAMIK BHATTACHARYA OWES BENGAL'S CHRISTIANS A PUBLIC APOLOGY

  A sweeping charge of forced conversion and "anti-India activities", unsupported by a single name, date or document, sits on top ...