A sweeping charge of forced
conversion and "anti-India activities", unsupported by a single name,
date or document, sits on top of a documented record of mobs raiding prayer
meetings. It is the accuser, not the accused, who has questions to answer.
A Charge Without an Address
On Sunday, standing on a dais in
New Alipore, the Bengal BJP president, Samik Bhattacharya, did what no
responsible leader should do: he indicted an entire community without naming a
single accused. Christian missionary schools, he suggested, force conversions.
They sneer at the attire of the majority. They harbour "anti-India
activities". Unless they mend their ways, he warned, the schools will not
be allowed to run.
Not one school was named. Not one
date was offered. No complainant, no FIR, no document was produced. What the
audience received instead were anecdotes with the proper nouns carefully
removed: an "elite college", a "prestigious school",
"a school in Calcutta". And a threat.
An allegation that cannot be
checked is not an allegation. It is a smear. And a smear delivered by the head
of the ruling party, in a state where Christian bodies say congregations are
already being raided on the strength of identical rumours, is not merely
irresponsible. It is dangerous.
"Asansol" and the Principal Who Has No
Name
"In Asansol, religious
conversion is currently taking place," Mr Bhattacharya declared, in the
present continuous tense, as though he were watching it unfold. In the same
speech he said the conversion was being run by the principal of an obhijato
college in Calcutta.
Which college? Which principal?
Which converts, converted through what force, what fraud, what bribe? Silence.
The Bangiya Christiya Pariseba
has answered the charge in plain words: no such conversion is taking place, and
it wants the government to investigate. Pause on that. The community accused of
a crime is begging the state to open an inquiry. The accuser, whose party runs
that state and its police, will not hand over a name. Who, exactly, has
something to hide?
The Pariseba did not stop at
denial. It said it opposes unlawful conversion, backs legal action against any
violator, and wants the allegations probed. Church bodies have reportedly gone
further, tightening their own safeguards so that those seeking to embrace
Christianity must submit a written application and an affidavit. That is not
how a conversion racket behaves. It is how a community behaves when it is
trying to protect itself from a false charge.
The Pakistani Flag Nobody Can Find
"Guardians, arise!" Mr
Bhattacharya cried, claiming that an official at a school had placed a
Pakistani flag on a table in a chamber somewhere in Calcutta.
If that is true, it is a matter
for the police and the education department, not a podium. The Christian forum
said as much: if such an act took place, it condemns it, and it asked him to
name the school. He has not. A leader who truly believed a school was
harbouring a hostile symbol would have filed a complaint the same day. Besides,
keeping various national flags is not a crime, – instead, it stands of
solidarity and unity. A leader who wants a rumour to do its work keeps the name
secret, because a rumour that cannot be tested also cannot be disproved.
The consequence is plain. By
refusing to name the institution, Mr Bhattacharya has placed every Christian
school in West Bengal under a cloud. Each principal, each teacher, each child
in a missionary uniform now carries a suspicion that he alone created and that
he alone can lift.
A Saffron Sari, a School Gate and a Threat
The third anecdote concerned a
young woman worker of his party, allegedly told by a "Bengali
teacher" at a "prestigious school" that she could not wear
saffron saris to the school and must never utter the name of Lord Krishna
before the students.
Note what this is: a second-hand
story, about an unnamed teacher, at an unnamed school, with no complaint on
record. If any teacher truly said such things, the remedy lies with the
school's governing body, the education department or the courts, and every
decent Christian institution would act on a proper complaint. Instead Mr
Bhattacharya announced, "in a few days, I'll stand at the school
gate."
Picture it. A party president,
flanked by party workers, planted at the gate of a school, in front of
children, to confront a teacher. That is not a grievance. That is pressure, and
the intended audience is every teacher in Bengal who is now being told to watch
what she says.
The contradiction is
breathtaking. In the same speech he said his party is "against political
intervention in any educational institution". Standing at the school gate
is political intervention in its purest form. As a recent Telegraph opinion piece
by Valson Thampu and Debasish Bhattacharyya reminded readers, when education
becomes an instrument of political mobilisation, overt or covert, its core
purpose is eroded. Schools are for learning. They are not stage sets for a
party's campaign.
Babur, the British and the Politics of Insult
"This government is not
Babur's government," Mr Bhattacharya thundered. "This government is
not trying to uphold British legacies." Seventy-five years on, he
lamented, the colonial "mentality has not gone".
Who is being addressed here? The
Bengali Catholic or Protestant who was born in Howrah or Barasat, who speaks
Bengali at home, who pays taxes and votes in Indian elections? To compare such
a citizen to a Mughal invader or a colonial administrator is the oldest trick
in the book: turn a neighbour into a foreigner, and every injustice done to him
becomes easier to excuse.
Christians in West Bengal are no
more "British" than Hindus are "Mughal". They are Bengalis.
They are Indians. Their faith is their business, protected by Article 25 of the
Constitution, and their right to establish and run their own educational
institutions is protected by Article 30. Mr Bhattacharya himself conceded in
the same breath that the Constitution has given missionary schools the
opportunity to propagate their religion. He cannot praise the Constitution in
one sentence and promise to override it in the next. A party president has no
power to "not let the school run". Only due process can do that, and
due process requires evidence he has refused to produce.
And what are we to make of
"no matter how big the force is"? Whose force? The police's? The
party's? The mob's? A leader billed as the "moderate face" of his
party should not need to be asked what such language invites.
The Law Already Exists. Use It.
Here the facts are not in
dispute, and they cut against Mr Bhattacharya's theatre rather than for it.
Conversion through coercion, fraud, misrepresentation or inducement is illegal.
The Supreme Court, in Rev. Stainislaus v. State of Madhya Pradesh in
1977, upheld state laws against conversion by force, fraud or inducement. The
Christian bodies of Bengal do not dispute any of it.
The real dispute is about proof
and process. A genuine complaint goes to the police. The police register an
FIR. An investigation follows, and then a court. At no stage in that chain does
a political leader get to convict a community from a stage, and at no stage
does a self-appointed crowd get to substitute for a magistrate.
The Bangya Christya Pariseba's co-founding
state secretary, Herod Mullick, put the real problem squarely. No investigation
is taking place, he said, while people take the law into their own hands,
attack churches and raise conversion allegations, and nobody stops them. That
is the scandal. Not the schools. The silence.
The Real Atrocities: Who Is Actually Under
Attack?
Mr Bhattacharya wants Bengal to
believe that the majority is under siege from a tiny minority. Christians
account for 0.72 per cent of the state's population in the 2011 Census. A
community of fewer than one in a hundred is accused of overwhelming the other
ninety-nine. The arithmetic alone should have given him pause.
Now look at the record he chose
to ignore.
A dossier compiled by multiple
Christian bodies, reported by this newspaper on November 9, documents what the
India Hate Lab counted as 60 distinct cases since May 4: 52 coordinated raids
on private prayer assemblies and domestic house churches, and eight violent mob
attacks, including physical assault. According to the researchers, perpetrators
routinely crash Sunday services on the pretext of demanding identification
documents, accuse congregants of forced conversion, vandalise crosses and burn
Bibles. Victims and fact-finding delegations have repeatedly named the RSS, the
Vishwa Hindu Parishad, the Bajrang Dal, the Hindu Jagran Manch and the
Anjani-Putra Sena. These are allegations which those organisations are free to
answer, and the proper place to test them is a court of law.
The pattern is not confined to
prayer halls. The dossier records burial rights being denied. It records
unannounced administrative visits in September to historic Christian
institutions after unverified social-media campaigns accused them of
proselytisation. At a seven-hour People's Tribunal on November 2, victims from
South 24-Parganas, North 24-Parganas, Howrah, East Midnapore and West Midnapore
described home attacks, destroyed life savings and the outraging of women's
modesty. Reporting elsewhere describes intruders at a September gathering in
Panskura invoking a "New Bengal" in which, they said, conversion
would no longer be tolerated.
The Pariseba had earlier told the
state that it counted 26 incidents in three months and that only 11 FIRs
followed. Christian leaders say none was properly investigated. In one reported
case, police allegedly stood by during a mob action and then arrested the
pastor himself on a charge of conducting conversion rites. The victim became
the accused.
The voices who sat through the
tribunal were not fringe activists. Jawhar Sircar, the former Prasar Bharati
chief, spoke of the despair of hearing case after case of helpless Christians
attacked, and of a police force too eager to curry favour. Aakar Patel warned
that majoritarian violence left unchecked by the state eventually fractures a
whole society. John Dayal, a veteran rights activist, said he had never seen
such intensity, viciousness and impunity in a pluralist, inclusive state like
Bengal.
This is the hooliganism that Mr
Bhattacharya's silence protects: hooligans who have appointed themselves
prosecutor, judge and executioner, and who make "conversion" the
password that unlocks any church door.
When a Rally Speech Becomes a Licence
The link between
the stage and the street is not hard to see. The vigilantes' favourite pretext
is the allegation of forced conversion, offered without proof. Mr
Bhattacharya's speech offered the same allegation, in the same form, without
proof, from a far more powerful platform.
At the same time in Mr Bhattacharya's own framing: he said that missionaries
may propagate their faith voluntarily and that he is not against any religion.
What a double-speaking!
One should know how the governing regime thinks
too. Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari said on October 4 that his government will
act against forced conversion. Supporters argue that coercive conversion is a
real concern that deserves scrutiny, particularly in tribal and poor areas.
Added to it, an RSS spokesperson has denied the charges on attacks on Christian
institutes and Churches, and said
Christian schools have adequate security.
When the president of the ruling
party tells "guardians" to rise against an unnamed school, the
hooligan at the back of the crowd does not hear a call for an inquiry. He hears
permission. That is why the CPI(M)'s Sujan Chakraborty called the remarks
criminal incitement over a baseless allegation, and why the Pariseba, in a
restrained statement, called such generalisation "deeply irresponsible,
condemnable, and dangerous". It asked, in the same statement, for action
against vigilante groups that vandalise peaceful prayer meetings.
Even within the ranks of those
sympathetic to the government, there is discomfort. A minister quoted by The
Federal has said that incidents of forced conversion, if any, should go to the
administration for legal action, and that nobody should take the law into their
own hands. Mr Bhattacharya should have said the same on Sunday. He did not.
A Community of Builders, Not Subversives
Bengal's missionary schools and
colleges have taught generations of children of every faith, and the great
majority of their students were never Christian. As a columnist in ThePrint
noted, many ministers in BJP-led governments were themselves educated in such
institutions, and many send their children abroad to Christian-majority
countries. The faith of those students was not taken from them. The
institutions are not "conversion factories".
The West Bengal Association of
Christian Schools and the Pariseba have pointed out that, over more than two
centuries, these institutions have expanded opportunity especially for the
marginalised and the poor. When those same schools felt threatened, they did
not threaten anyone in return. They approached the state human rights
commission. They asked to meet the RSS leadership. A five-member Pariseba
delegation sat down with the RSS state head on November 5. That is how a
community with nothing to hide, and everything to lose, behaves.
Contrast that conduct with a
leader who will not give a name, will not file a complaint, and has chosen the
language of ultimatums.
What an Honest Leader Would Do
Mr Bhattacharya has a simple
choice, and it is a choice between accountability and slander.
First, he should place before the
police and the education department, within a reasonable time, the names of the
institutions he alleges are engaged in forced conversion, harbour a Pakistani
flag or discriminate against saffron-wearing women, along with whatever
evidence he holds. If he has it, the law will take its course. If he does not,
he should say so.
Second, if he cannot or will not
produce proof, he owes Bengal's Christians, and its teachers and students, an
unconditional public apology, and a withdrawal of the blanket charge that
missionary schools are engaged in "anti-India activities".
Third, he should disown his own
threat to stand at a school gate, and promise that no party worker will do so.
Fourth, he should condemn by name
the vigilante raids on prayer meetings, and demand of his own government what
the Pariseba has asked: FIRs registered, perpetrators arrested, places of
worship protected.
The Christians of Bengal are not
asking for favours. They are asking for what any citizen of a constitutional
republic may ask: that accusations be backed by evidence, that grievances be
settled by law and not by mobs, and that the state protect them rather than the
people who attack them.
A politician who calls himself a
moderate must prove it when moderation is hard, not when it is easy. Samik
Bhattacharya made a serious accusation against a whole community on Sunday. He
has one honourable way out. Name the school, show the proof, or say sorry.

No comments:
Post a Comment